Can we speak of a high commitment management on the shop floor

Article Abstract:

The Commitment model a la Walton has been a key element in conceptions of human resource management (HRM). Is there though any evidence of its application to production workers? Drawing on the HRM literature the authors first develop some measures of practices which might be thought to contribute to high commitment management (HCM). Having acquired data on the extent to which organizations adopt these practices the authors then, using latent variable analysis, assess whether there is a common structure underlying it which represents some kind of HCM-type approach to labour. In so doing they develop a construct to measure HCM relevant to manual workers. Basing the analysis on data from a representative sample of manufacturing plants in the UK, they conclude that HCM is being practised, albeit to a very varying degree. The research also reveals a growth in the use of HCM practices between 1986 and 1990, and that this has been mainly in practices already popular in 1986; hence the increased use of HCM has been more in plants for whom it was relatively insignificant in 1986, rather than a further heightening of its significance in plants for which it was important before. Using multiple regression analysis, the authors are also able to show that organizational factors rather than factors exogenous to the organization are significantly related to both the level of HCM, and its rate of change between 1986 and 1990. Of overwhelming importance is the extent of the strategic integration of personnel management. The authors draw out the relevance of the study for the wider debate about HRM. In particular the results add some support for Walton's and Guest's universalistic theories of HCM, as opposed to what have been called matching or contingency theories of HCM, according to which it is only likely to be found in specific contexts where, for example, high quality is important for competitive advantage. (Reprinted by permission of the publisher.)

Management, Commitment (Psychology), Factory management

---

Human resource strategy and competitive advantage: a longitudinal study of engineering consultancies

Article Abstract:

Concepts associated with the resource-based view of the firm are increasingly finding their way into the strategic HRM debate. Drawing on this literature, this paper reports one of the first industry-based, longitudinal investigations into the relationship between human resource strategy and competitive advantage. Set in New Zealand, but in an internationally oriented sector, the study examines one of the more neglected spheres of professional services: engineering consultancies. The results indicate that the consultancy firms that survived the major business traumas of the late 1980s and early 1990s adopted similar structural, competitive, operational and HR responses associated with their evolving 'industry recipe.' In interpreting the relationship between HRM and firm performance, then, it is important to distinguish those features of a firm's HRM which are strategic to ongoing viability from those that might form the basis of a relatively enduring form of competitive advantage. While there is insufficient evidence to conclude that any of the primary subjects in this study have established an enviable form of superiority, the study suggests that opportunities do exist for professional service firms to develop industry leadership through superior HRM. The analysis has implications for the wider work of theory-building in strategic HRM. (Reprinted by permission of the publisher.)

Management consulting services, Other Management Consulting Services, Business & Mgmt Consulting NEC, Services, New Zealand, Consulting services, Consulting engineers

---

Human resourcing in practice: managing employment issues in the university

Article Abstract:

Participant observation in two universities is used to throw light on processes of sensemaking engaged in by managers concerned with human resourcing issues. Analysis of managerial sensemaking in the case study organizations is carried out using concepts from earlier sociological theorizing about human resource or personnel management, treating these theoretical ideas as resources for use in the researchers' own sensemaking. It is shown that theoretical 'sense' can be made of the managerial or 'lay' sensemaking in the universities in terms of a need to handle various tensions which are inherent in all employment management work in industrial capitalist societies. And it is argued that there is clear continuity between what is currently occurring and has occurred in the past. This interpretation is shown to differ from that of an alternative approach in social science sensemaking, that which uses the notion of a new paradigm of 'HRM.' (Reprinted by permission of the publisher.)

Case studies, Human resource management )

Similar abstracts:

• Abstracts: Estimating the cost of capital through time: an analysis of the sources of error. Delay cost and incentive schemes for multiple users
• Abstracts: The changing rules of global competitiveness in the 21st century. Legal issues in multinational business strategy: to play the game, you have to know the rules
• Abstracts: Candidates falling into the open arms of high technology. Merrill enters trading world of the Internet
• Abstracts: The evolution patterns of quality management: some reflections on the quality movement. Vision 2000: positioning the new ISO 9000 standards with respect to total quality management models
• Abstracts: Cultivating a quality mind-set. Process orientation: the Swedish experience. Maximizing the benefits of ISO 9000 implementation

This website is not affiliated with document authors or copyright owners. This page is provided for informational purposes only. Unintentional errors are possible.