After Zurko: true deference or magic words?
Article Abstract:
Zurko is a term used to refer to a 1990 patent application from Mary E. Zurko and others. The application disclosed/claimed a method for improving security in a computer system that could operate with both untrusted and trusted code. The patent examiner rejected the claims as obvious, given some prior art references. The applicants appealed. The legal ramfications, involving the US Patent and Trademark Office, the courts, including the Supreme Court, and other cases are discussed. The standard of review applied by the Federal Circuit will be largely irrelevant for many cases. Remand seems to be an option in cases in which the PTO record is not good enough to allow the Federal Circuit to make a decision. The Federal Circuit can repeatedly send cases back until the PTO backs up its decision. Time and expense may make that unattractive.
Publication Name: Chemical Innovation
Subject: Engineering and manufacturing industries
ISSN: 1527-4799
Year: 2000
User Contributions:
Comment about this article or add new information about this topic:
New challenge for patent attorneys
Article Abstract:
A new challenge has emerged for patent attorneys as the result of a recent court decision that might radically change the way in which patent applications are prosecuted through the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. The Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has drastically limited the application of theC doctrine of equivalents to the interpretation of patent claims. It holds that whenever a patent claim is narrowed for any reason related to patentability, the prosecution history estoppel may be found relative to the amended claim element, even if the claim amendment is voluntary or unexplained. If the ruling is upheld, a premium will be on obtaining patents with a bare minimum of claim amendments.
Publication Name: Chemical Innovation
Subject: Engineering and manufacturing industries
ISSN: 1527-4799
Year: 2001
User Contributions:
Comment about this article or add new information about this topic:
Patent protection for bioinformatics tools
Article Abstract:
An overview is presented on patent law for bioinformatics, a synthesis of biotechnology and computer science. Topics include intellectual property and significant protections of core bioinformatics processes such as user data-request interfaces, profiles, and algorithms that mine, manipulate and analyze data.
Publication Name: Chemical Innovation
Subject: Engineering and manufacturing industries
ISSN: 1527-4799
Year: 2000
User Contributions:
Comment about this article or add new information about this topic:
- Abstracts: Engineering education: the challenge of reform. Education reform: pros and cons. The impacts of technology on engineering education
- Abstracts: An integrated dynamic performance measurement system for improving manufacturing competitiveness. An example of the application of production system design tools for the implementation of business process reengineering
- Abstracts: A new role for e-beam: electron projection. Power to the package. The fine art of IC design
- Abstracts: Recover heat from hot solids. Use peer-review of chemical processes for extra safety. Negotiate a favorable air operating permit
- Abstracts: Nitric oxide - from pollutant to product. From raw sugar to raw materials. Teaching old platinum compounds new tricks