Court-assisted ethicide; two courtroom decisions on physician-assisted suicide undermine the ethical standard of 'First, do no harm.'(Editorial)

Article Abstract:

Judicial sanction of physician-assisted suicide is a devastating attack on long-standing medical ethics. The tenet that physicians should 'do no harm' is fundamental to medical ethics, and the two courtroom rulings favoring the physician-assisted suicide, and the reasoning behind them, are wrong. In one case, a federal appeals court in San Francisco, CA, dismissed a Washington state prohibition of the practice, reasoning that it was a logical progression from other ethically sound medical practices. Meanwhile a jury in Pontiac, MI, found Dr Jack Kervorkian innocent of assisting in the suicides of two patients. The latter case may yet be appealed to the Supreme Court.

Other Justice, Public Order, and Safety Activities, Physicians & Surgeons, Offices of Physicians (except Mental Health Specialists), Criminal Law NEC, Evaluation, Medicine, Practice, Assisted suicide, Medical practice, Criminal law

---

Release of disciplinary data highly charged

Article Abstract:

State health departments are weighing whether or not to disclose the names of physicians who have been charged with misconduct. Such cases may take years to resolve and are sometimes based on trivial matters. The New York State Department of Health has published a newsletter containing the names of physicians who have been charged with misconduct but may discontinue the practice because of the intense media attention it focused on a few physicians. Consumer groups have been pressuring states to disclose more physician misconduct data.

Health aspects, Consumer protection, Social policy, New York. Department of Health

---

Medical profession aims to police itself

Article Abstract:

Physicians' efforts to set standards for ethical conduct have been undermined by the Department of Justice and Federal Trade Commission's use of antitrust law applied to doctors as ordinary businessmen. On the other hand, Congress and the Health Care Financing Administrations set regulations contrary to the assumption that medicine is a business. The proposal of the Chicago Medical Association and AMA to set up a fee mediation committee represents a step in the right direction.

Standards

Similar abstracts:

• Abstracts: Substituted judgement: how accurate are proxy predictions? The debate over physician-assisted suicide: empirical data and convergent views
• Abstracts: Market forces and health care costs. Consolidation of medical groups into physician practice management organizations
• Abstracts: Ascorbic acid and adriamycin toxicity. Interactions between ascorbic acid and the radiation of bone marrow, skin, and tumor
• Abstracts: Medicine at center stage. Primary care and the affliction of internal medicine
• Abstracts: Where is medicine's enemy? Sometimes it's in the mirror. When was it that physicians became the bad guys?

This website is not affiliated with document authors or copyright owners. This page is provided for informational purposes only. Unintentional errors are possible.