Diagnosis and management of adults with pharyngitis: a cost-effectiveness analysis

Article Abstract:

Background: Rheumatic fever has become uncommon in the United States while rapid diagnostic test technology for streptococcal antigens has improved. However, little is known about the effectiveness or cost-effectiveness of various strategies for managing pharyngitis caused by group A beta-hemolytic streptococcus (GAS) in U.S. adults. Objective: To examine the cost-effectiveness of several diagnostic and management strategies for patients with suspected GAS pharyngitis. Design: Cost-effectiveness analysis. Data Sources: Published literature, including systematic reviews where possible. When costs were not available in the literature, we estimated them from our institution and Medicare charges. Target Population: Adults in the general U.S. population. Time Horizon: 1 year. Perspective: Societal. Interventions: Five strategies for the management of adult patients with pharyngitis: 1) observation without testing or treatment, 2) empirical treatment with penicillin, 3) throat culture using a two-plate selective culture technique, 4) optical immunoassay (OIA) followed by culture to confirm negative OIA test results, or 5) OIA alone. Outcome Measures: Cost per lost quality-adjusted life-days (converted to life-years where appropriate) and incremental cost-effectiveness. Results of Base-Case Analysis: Empirical treatment was the least effective strategy at a GAS pharyngitis prevalence of 10% (resulting in 0.41 lost quality-adjusted life-day). Although the other four strategies had similar effectiveness (all resulted in about 0.27 lost quality-adjusted life-day), culture was the least expensive strategy. Results of Sensitivity Analyses: Results were sensitive to the prevalence of GAS pharyngitis: OIA followed by culture was most effective when GAS pharyngitis prevalence was greater than 20%. Observation was least expensive when prevalence was less than 6%, and empirical treatment was least expensive when prevalence was greater than 71%. The effectiveness of strategies was also very sensitive to the probability of anaphylaxis: when the probability of anaphylaxis was about half the baseline probability, OIA/culture was most effective; when the probability was 1.6 times that of baseline, observation was most effective. Only at an OIA cost less than half of baseline did the OIA alone strategy become less effective than culture. Results were not sensitive to other variations in probabilities or costs of diagnosis or treatment of GAS pharyngitis. Conclusions: Observation, culture, and two rapid antigen test strategies for diagnostic testing and treatment of suspected GAS pharyngitis in adults have very similar effectiveness and costs, although culture is the least expensive and most effective strategy when the GAS pharyngitis prevalence is 10%. Empirical treatment was not the most effective or least expensive strategy at any prevalence of GAS pharyngitis in adults, although it may be reasonable for individual patients at very high risk for GAS pharyngitis as assessed by a clinical decision rule.

Diagnosis, Streptococcus pyogenes, Pharyngitis, Sore throat, Author Abstract

---

Update in hospital medicine

Article Abstract:

Important research on the treatment and outcomes of hospital patients published in 1999 is reviewed. Topics include heart attack, chronic obstructive lung diseases, infection control, catheter infections, venous thromboembolism, and terminal care.

---

Update in hospital medicine

Article Abstract:

Research published in 2000 on the care of hospital patients is reviewed. Topics include critical care, infectious diseases, end-of-life care, heart disease, gastrointestinal disease, and the quality of medical care.

Similar abstracts:

• Abstracts: Pain management of mixed aetiology ulcers. Community-based leg ulcer clinics: organisation and cost-effectiveness
• Abstracts: Rapid diagnosis and classification of hydatidiform moles with polymerase chain reaction. Expression of human telomerase reverse transcriptase, the catalytic subunit of telomerase, is associated with the development of persistent disease in complete hydatidiform moles
• Abstracts: Tracheostomy management: Patients who have a tracheostomy present many challenges to nurses. Preparing the patient for tracheostomy tube removal
• Abstracts: Recent trends in the identification and treatment of high blood cholesterol by physicians: progress and missed opportunities
• Abstracts: Does this child have acute otitis media? Do opiates affect the clinical evaluation of patients with acute abdominal pain?

This website is not affiliated with document authors or copyright owners. This page is provided for informational purposes only. Unintentional errors are possible.